Gideon’s Bakehouse Review: Are the Cookies Really Worth the Wait?
If you’re planning a trip to Walt Disney World and your feed has been filled with ooey-gooey, half-pound cookies, you’ve probably heard of Gideon’s Bakehouse in Disney Springs. Known for its gothic vibes and indulgent cookies, Gideon’s is one of the most hyped dessert spots on Disney property, and for good reason.
But here’s the real scoop: Gideon’s is absolutely worth it… if you know how to do it right. First-timers, this one’s for you!
What Is Gideon’s Bakehouse?
Tucked into The Landing at Disney Springs, Gideon’s Bakehouse is a boutique dessert shop famous for its:
- Half-pound cookies loaded with chocolate, peanut butter, and seasonal surprises
- Tall, gooey cake slices
- Cold brew coffee with cult followings of their own
- Spooky, storybook-style decor that makes the wait almost part of the fun
The shop originated in Orlando and quickly became a Disney Springs sensation. But it’s not just the treats, it’s the entire experience.
The Truth About the Wait (and How to Beat It)
Let’s get one thing out of the way: there will be a wait. Sometimes 1–3 hours. But here’s how to make the most of it:
✅ Queue Strategy 101:
- Arrive early: Doors open at 10 a.m., and the line starts before that.
- Virtual Queue: If the line gets long, they switch to a virtual queue. Check in with the Cast Member out front and you’ll get a text when it’s your turn. You can shop, eat, or chill by the water in the meantime.
- Late night hack: Lines tend to die down around 9–10 p.m. (especially weekdays), but popular cookies may sell out.
📸 Pro tip: Use the wait time to explore Disney Springs or grab a bite at nearby quick-service spots like The Polite Pig or Chicken Guy.
Best Gideon’s Cookies (Ranked!)
Everyone has their faves, but here’s how they stack up for first-timers:
- Original Chocolate Chip – A classic. Crunchy outside, gooey inside, and rolled in chocolate chips. If you try one cookie, make it this one.
- Peanut Butter Crunch – A salty-sweet dream. Great for peanut butter lovers.
- Cookies & Cream – Like an Oreo cookie on steroids. Kid-approved.
- Pistachio Toffee Chocolate Chip – A grown-up twist with a hint of salt and sophistication.
- Limited Edition Flavors – These change monthly and often sell out fast. Check their Instagram or ask the Cast Member what’s available.
🍰 Bonus: If you love cake, don’t skip the Coffee Cake Cookie (AM only!) or a slice of their rotating layer cakes.
Is Gideon’s Worth It?
YES… if you plan ahead.
- For Instagrammable treats? 10/10
- For unique Disney Springs snacks? Absolutely.
- If you’re in a rush? Might want to skip.
- For picky eaters or kids? Stick to the classic chocolate chip or cookies & cream.
When to Skip Gideon’s
As magical as Gideon’s is, it’s not for every trip:
- You’re short on time or dealing with cranky kids
- You don’t love super-sweet desserts
- You’re on a strict budget (cookies run about $6 each)
- You’re not prepared for the wait (no mobile order available)
What to Know Before You Go
- Each person can buy up to 6 cookies
- They do sell out of flavors, especially limited editions
- The cold brew is strong and very sweet
- There’s no seating, so plan to take your treats to-go
Final Verdict: Worth It With a Plan
Gideon’s Bakehouse lives up to the hype if you go in with a smart strategy. The cookies are decadent, the vibe is immersive, and the whole thing makes for a fun Disney foodie adventure.
Ready to bite into the magic? Let me know which cookie you’re dying to try in the comments below or tag me on Instagram with your Gideon’s haul! #DisneySnackGoals
- Gideon’s Bakehouse Review: Are the Cookies Really Worth the Wait?
- Behind the Seeds Tour at EPCOT: Disney’s Most Underrated (and Affordable!) VIP Experience
- Last-Minute Disney World Planning: How to Book an Incredible Trip in 30 Days or Less
- Behind the Magic #5: Final Prep for Our Long Weekend at the Dolphin + Why We Chose to Rent a Car
- Behind the Magic Trip Diary #4: Planning Our Holiday Trip Park Days, Resort Hopping & Must-Dos!
